Selling coins shouldn’t feel like a guessing game. At Coinfully, we make it easy to sell your coins online with full transparency, expert support, and no-pressure service — all from the comfort of your home.
Whether you’ve inherited a collection or built one over years of passionate collecting, the process of parting with it can be emotional and, too often, frustrating. Many people start with excitement, only to be let down by confusing pricing, lowball offers, and the hassle of visiting local dealers. We’ve been there. Coinfully was created by lifelong collectors who believed there had to be a better, more respectful way to sell coins — one that combined modern technology with deep numismatic expertise.
That’s exactly what we’ve built.
Coinfully offers a streamlined, fully digital appraisal process that’s fast, safe, and fair. You don’t need to pack up your collection and drive across town or waste time with vague offers from people who may not know what they’re looking at. Our process is built to give you the tools and expert insight you need to make confident decisions.
With Coinfully, selling coins online is as easy as three simple steps:
We even offer a concierge appraisal service, traveling directly to you for large or historically significant collections.
We understand coins, because we’ve lived coins. Coinfully is led by brothers Travis and Wyatt McDonald — second-generation numismatists who grew up in the world of rare coins, attending major shows and working with world-class collections. Their mother, Deborah McDonald, introduced them to the trade in the 1990s, and she remains a trusted numismatist on the team today.
Our team also includes renowned experts like Douglas Winter, one of the most respected authorities in rare U.S. gold coins and an award-winning numismatic author.
As a family-run business, we bring the values of trust, fairness, and education to every interaction. We’re not just trying to “make a deal.” We’re here to give you real answers about your coins, even if you’re not ready to sell. That’s why we created the Instant Value Guide, a free online resource that helps you quickly understand what makes coins valuable — even before speaking with an expert.
Unlike traditional coin shops and auction houses, Coinfully uses technology to reduce overhead and reach collectors across the globe. That means we can offer better prices and a faster process than most brick-and-mortar dealers — and we pass those savings on to you.
We also believe in full transparency. There’s never pressure to sell. We explain how offers are determined, walk you through comparable sales when possible, and empower you with knowledge every step of the way.
And with our insured shipping process and private in-home appraisal option, you stay in control the entire time.
We’re proud to be trusted and certified by some of the most respected institutions in the numismatic world, including:
These partnerships reflect our commitment to professionalism, security, and ethical standards in everything we do.
Email: info@coinfully.com
Phone: 704-621-4893
Location: 401 Hawthorne Ln, Ste 110-323, Charlotte, NC 28204
Website: www.coinfully.com